HOW TO SPOT AUTHENTIC MAJOLICA

June 05, 2019 3 min read 25 Comments

HOW TO SPOT AUTHENTIC MAJOLICA

Have you fallen under its spell?

I have! I have a secret obsession for antique majolica, I won't lie.

With their jewel toned hues, whimsical shapes, and all-out personality

majolica has been adding joie de vivre to French Country style lovers' homes for hundreds of years!

Prized for being hand made originals, each one took hours of design and "making" -

majolica pieces are considered works of art today rather than every day pottery.

It's easy to see why the styles are so coveted by designers and collectors alike.

Majolica has a rich history, you can read more about it HERE >

and how to decorate with it HERE >

Today I'm sharing a few tips on how to tell if a piece is authentic, or a modern reproduction.

When it comes to buying majolica for your home and collection,

you have to take into account your personal taste, and price range.

There are real, authentic majolica pieces in every range and quality!

These tips will allow you to buy pieces that are a true art form.

1. STUDY. The best way to be able to spot a modern reproduction of majolica is to go visit some in real life. Go to a museum, an antique dealer's collection, or look at some of the pieces of authentic majolica we sell here at FrenchGardenHouse on our website. 2. QUALITY. The new majolica is clearly inferior to true, 19th and early 20th century pieces. They're second-rate copies. They won't have the same careful painting, sharply molded details, nor that "wow" factor that a true antique piece of majolica will have. 3. GLAZE COLOR. Old, authentic majolica is very colorful, their glazes will have a rich, lustrous color hue. Modern reproductions will be much more garish in their colors. While the true antique majolica pieces are carefully glazed, the new pieces can be sloppy, with drips and glaze runs. The production lines of newer copies don't allow for the same careful quality control that the Victorian pieces had. 4. WEIGHT. Antique majolica will have a certain weight to it. They are heavy pieces. Modern reproductions will be much, much "lighter" 5. UNDERSURFACE. The antique majolica pieces will have a body underneath the glaze that is pink, blue, green, golden yellow, or cream. Some pieces have a "mottled" undersurface of blue-brown, blue-black. Newer pieces will most likely have a white undersurface. 6. MARKS. Many 19th century majolica manufacturers clearly marked their wares. But there are plenty of smaller manufacturers such as beloved Joseph Holdcraft, who did not. Today's reproductions are either unmarked, or often have a pretend British diamond shaped registry mark on the bottom. 7. CONDITION. Most of us collectors seek out the most pristine pieces we can find. Large chips or cracks that go all the way through a piece are hard to accept. Dull glazing or looks too heavy is another thing not many collectors want to see in their cherished majolica collection. But once in a while, we can get carried away by a piece that has been repaired. If you are not a perfectionist, there are plenty of majolica beauties out there waiting for you, at a much friendlier price than the 500.- to thousands {or more!} pieces that would literally mean taking a chunk out of your year's food budget. 8. COMMON SENSE. If a piece of majolica seems very inexpensive and the price seems too good to be true, it probably IS.

I hope you become as smitten with these charming creations as we are here at FrenchGardenHouse!

There is such delight in arranging your collection of majolica throughout your home.

Each colorful piece adds a touch of history, French Country charm,

and exudes your personal style and taste.

ps. There are modern reproductions, made by reputable manufactures, that are marked with their own factory name and, often, the date of production.

DO YOU LOVE MAJOLICA?

à bientôt

25 Responses

frenchgardenhouse
frenchgardenhouse

January 22, 2024

Carol, unfortunately we are not appraisers. There are services that will let you know about your piece for a nominal fee, even online ones. Or ask at a local antique store if they know of a local antique appraiser to help you. Good luck!

Caz
Caz

January 22, 2024

I have a large vase two handles .greenand blue with cherubs on.. the handles are of pink fish .marks on bottom y.in a sheild and99 or66 I’ve had this piece for 40 years can you help

Lidy
Lidy

July 05, 2023

Jodie, unfortunately we are not appraisers. If you wanted someone to identify your plate and give you a value, you will be able to find antique appraisers online fairly easily who will, for a small fee, identify your piece for you. Good luck!

Jodie Keith
Jodie Keith

July 04, 2023

I believe I have an 8" Majolica plate. Haven’t been able to find it anywhere on the internet. It has a Red Flower and a Purple flower (with yellow center) along with 5 small blue flowers in the center of the plate. On the back of the plate is faint “Made in Italy” Would you be able to tell me if this is a Majolica plate, and what it may be valued at? Look forward to your reply

Hayley Gerrard
Hayley Gerrard

April 22, 2022

Hello, I wonder if you would be able to help me identify a jardiniere that I have that I think is possibly majolica but I’m struggling to correctly identify it. Many thanks ?

Lidy
Lidy

February 01, 2022

Pamela, I’m so sorry, we don’t value antiques or other decorative pieces, that is not our expertise. There are many trained professionals that will do that for you for a small fee. You can either contact a local antique shop and ask them if they can refer someone to you, or look online under antique appraisals.

Pamela Mahrouch
Pamela Mahrouch

January 30, 2022

Can you please tell me approximately how old my Majolica piece is and more information about it please and approximately how much it is valued at? Any help would greatly be appreciated and a blessing. I can email you pictures if you send me a email address to send them to so you can see it.

Robert Danzman
Robert Danzman

December 29, 2021

Is it possible for you, or some other expert, to comment on a piece from photographs submitted? I think it’s Majolica. It was a piece included in the purchase of the entire inventory of an antique shop in a Philadelphia, Pennsylvania suburb in 1971.

Lidy
Lidy

October 31, 2021

Carol, unfortunately I’m not an expert in Wedgwood. Some of the earlier Majolica wasn’t marked, and to add to the confusion even more, several factories produced almost identical pieces from molds. Saying that, Wedgwood began marking their pieces in 1759 with an impressed mark. The only way to know for sure is to hire a specialist appraiser.

Carol McLaughlin
Carol McLaughlin

October 31, 2021

Do you know if early Wedgwood was ever produced without a makers mark on the bottom? I have a Majolica sunflower basket platter, identical mold to the one by Wedgewood but lacking any impressed mark. The only bottom marking on mine are two navy blue dots. I would say it is older than similar ones I see online and the colors are beautiful….soft and muted.
Thanks
Carol McLaughlin

Lidy
Lidy

June 23, 2021

Mary, there are online antique appraisers who may be able to help you. Or perhaps there is a local antique shop who can steer you in the right direction. Good luck!

Mary K
Mary K

June 22, 2021

I have a vase that is signed, I believe it is of the majolica kind, kind, it is signed with initials, and assi, Italy (Assisi)
Where can I research it at? Or where can I post a picture of it, to research it?

Lidy
Lidy

June 07, 2021

Linda, majolica was made in several countries, by a whole bunch of manufacturers. Many are signed, but many are not!

linda brooks
linda brooks

June 07, 2021

I have a footed compote that I mostly pink with a vine design with some small flowers all over the outside and just the pink inside. The footed base is open and the mark is in the open area. Does all Majolika have the same mark or does it vary by artist?

Lidy
Lidy

April 20, 2021

Jackie, I’m so sorry, we don’t do valuations nor have an identification service. I suggest you contact a local antique shop.

Jackie
Jackie

April 20, 2021

Hi
I hope you are well. I have been given a beautiful piece with a squirrel in the centre. It’s underside is a golden yellow and has a stamp mark of JJ. It doesn’t have any other markings Would you be able to tell me anything else I could look out for to determine whether it’s a fake or a real piece. Kind Regards
Jackie xx

Connie Heard
Connie Heard

November 20, 2020

Hi I love your educational piece on the wonderful French majolica. I am new to learning and collecting. I have a cache pot with the number 356. Is that the part of the the location in France it came from?? It has something marks which are unreadable.
Thank-you’

Angela Kenn
Angela Kenn

November 15, 2020

Your website is lovely. Thank you for such great quality.

Would you be so kind as to refer me to a museum quality restorer for majolica?

Any help would be appreciated.

Christopher Todd Smith
Christopher Todd Smith

March 06, 2020

I think I found my first piece. It has P 134 on the bottom. It is a blackberry pitcher with a wood looking handle. I hope it is real. It doesn’t have any chips or cracks. It had kitchen grease on it like it was sitting on display on top of a cabinet for years.

Lidy
Lidy

February 11, 2020

Lynda, I’m so sorry, but we aren’t appraisers at FrenchGardenHouse. There are businesses and/or dealers who will help you identify antiques for fee, I think you will be able to find those through google. Good luck! It’s always exciting to find out the history of something in your collection!

Lynda Henkel
Lynda Henkel

February 11, 2020

I’m needing help to identify a Majolica container I purchased 30 years ago
Can you help me I could send pictures

Nancy Brantley
Nancy Brantley

June 05, 2019

I’m a collector of old Majolica. I’ve been collecting for years when I would spy a piece at a reasonable price. I have a China Cabinet full.

Sandra at Maison De Jardin
Sandra at Maison De Jardin

June 05, 2019

Lidy, this is a wonderful post. And most informative. I so wish I had read this a few weeks ago, as my heart sank when I read that food should not be placed on Majolica. I just received a beautiful Majolica Oyster Platter which I ordered as a gift for my husband’s upcoming birthday. He does love oysters and always complains that his current oyster plate does not hold enough – it has places for 6. So when I found this platter, I was thrilled. It is in perfect condition and is marked on the back Gien with their marking and has what looks like DE BIEH to the side with a fancy scroll and the #’s 29 and then the initials ID. Any thoughts you might send my way as to using it and its authenticity would be ever so appreciated. Again, a wonderful post.

Sharon Crigger-Stokan
Sharon Crigger-Stokan

June 05, 2019

Such beautiful pieces of majolica were’scattered’ throughout your post today. I particularly loved the pitcher. Thank you for all the tips, links and info to help us out, Lidy!

Rita C at Panoply
Rita C at Panoply

June 05, 2019

I do love majolica! This and the linked article are both very informative, Lidy. My majolica is still packed in storage, but I’m anxious to start having fun with decor again here in our new abode. It has the basics, but needs more layers of soul added. :)

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


How to Enjoy Small Holiday Moments

How to Enjoy Small Holiday Moments

December 02, 2024 3 min read

Today I'm sharing a small holiday moment and little area we enjoy here at FrenchGardenHouse.
Read More
antique tea cups

Grateful for Friendship Tea

November 19, 2024 3 min read 2 Comments

Raise your cup to friendship and welcome to November's Tea on Tuesdays! You'll find table inspiration and all things tea.
Read More
Set a stunning Thanksgiving table

How to Set a Beautifully Welcoming Thanksgiving Table Setting with Antiques

November 04, 2024 4 min read 5 Comments

Learn how to mix and match antique with new items and how to use simple decorations to make every guest feel special. Here's How to Set a Beautifully Welcoming Thanksgiving Table Setting with Antiques.
Read More